The Science of Gabions Towards Erosion Control

29 Apr.,2024

 

The Science of Gabions Towards Erosion Control

The Science of Gabions Towards Erosion Control

Soil erosion is a prevalent problem in both rural and urban areas. If left uncontrolled, it could lead to loss of topsoil, which is vital for planting and vegetation growth. One of the most effective ways of controlling soil erosion is using gabion walls.

Click here to get more.

What are Gabion walls?

Gabion walls are box-shaped wire baskets made from a hexagonal mesh of galvanized steel wire. The “boxes” are filled with durable rock fragments and stacked on top of one another to form a gravity wall.

Gabion walls depend primarily on the rock fragments' compactness to maintain internal stability and their weight to resist hydraulic and earth forces.

What are they used for?

Gabion walls are mainly constructed to gently slow down the speed of run-off while sieving the soil it carries. They are also used to alleviate seepage problems on slopes. This mainly occurs on loose soils. They can also be used in areas with water-soil problems, where the land conditions, water velocity, water turbulence, and expected vegetative cover are set in a way that may erode the soil in the design flow conditions.

Gabions also play a pivotal role in road construction. In road construction, gabion walls stabilize the road, mainly when the road is being constructed on a slope.

History of Gabions

Gabion walls date back to 7000 years ago when the Egyptians used them to control flood waters from the river Nile. They wove gabion baskets using reeds, filled them up with small rocks, and arranged them along the Nile. The result was a significant decline in the river's erosion and the prevention of run-off flood water that destroyed their crops during the rainy season.

Military use

In medieval times, gabions were used as an inverted trench that protected soldiers from enemy fire. This method was also used during the American Civil War. These early gabion designs had open tops and bottoms. They were made from wickerwork and filled with earth to act as military fortifications.

These gabion walls were used to protect siege artillery gunners and scrappers. The wickerwork cylinders were relatively light and could be carried easily along the ammunition train. At the battlefield, they could be stood on end, stacked on end, and filled with earth to form an effective wall around the gun. They could also be used as a bulletproof parapet along with a sap.

When the Crimean War transpired, there was a scarcity of brushwood. This led soldiers to utilize scrap hoop-iron obtained from hay bales. This design inspired the creation of iron-filled gabion walls.

Today, the military uses gabion walls to safeguard their bases against fragmentary, explosive, mortar, or artillery fire. Examples of forwarding operating bases (FOBs) that use gabion walls are mess halls, sleeping quarters, and any other areas that house a large concentration of unprotected soldiers.

Civil Engineering

The most common use of gabion walls in civil engineering came about in the late 1800s in order to stabilize shorelines, slopes, and stream banks against soil erosion. Other applications in this realm include retaining walls, temporary floodwalls, noise barriers, silt filtration from run-off, river training, channel lining, and construction of temporary dams.

Over the years, the use of gabion walls has diversified as they are used in both military and civil engineering projects. Some architects have also incorporated gabion walls in their designs. Gabion walls accentuate the building's design and give it a sturdy feel, not to mention the added aesthetic appeal they provide.

Types of Gabions

The type of gabion used in any project depends on cost and function. That being said, there are four types of gabions. They include:

  1. Gabion Baskets

Gabion baskets are generally made of wire mesh and constructed in box shapes. They vary in size and are mainly used in highway and railway projects. Gabion baskets are an economical choice for any project, especially if the filler material is available on-site.

  1. Gabion Mattress

Also known as Reno mattresses, gabion mattresses have a lower height than other types. They are mostly used in channel lining to prevent erosion. They deal with wave and erosion-induced erosion by reducing water velocity.

  1. Gabion Sacks

This type of gabion is made from porous, flexible structures including cylindrical wire mesh constructions. They are mainly used in hydraulic works in emergencies since they can be built quickly.

  1. Gabion Wire Mesh

This type of gabion design is used to protect railway and highway surfaces from rock and stone falls. They maintain the slope's stability adjacent to the railways and highways and are also used as anti-erosion agents by providing a reinforced cover over the loose material.

Applications of Gabion walls

Gabion walls are often used as retaining structures such as revetment and tower walls, retaining walls, and embankments and cuttings. They can also be utilized as noise barriers, temporary floodwalls, or for aesthetic purposes including landscape elements and veneers. Riverbank defenses, sea walls, dams, canal banks, groins, and weirs are applications to prevent erosion and protect lakesides and reservoirs. Gabion walls can also be utilized to divert the force of floodwater around weak structures or in the construction of dams and foundations. Lastly, they can be used to enhance energy dissipation in channels, as is the case with stepped gabion structures.

Advantages of Gabions over other Erosion Control Methods

  1. Durability

Gabions are the most durable of all forms of soil erosion control methods. They also have a high resistance to atmospheric corrosion, brought about by the bonded zinc coating on the wire mesh and optional PVC coating. Gabion walls can also support vegetative growth at the top, which acts as a shield against the elements and provides additional reinforcement by interlocking with the onsite soils.

  1. Permeability

Gabion walls provide easy and instantaneous drainage. This eliminates the need for drainage pipes in most applications.

  1. Flexibility

Gabion walls can settle and deform without losing their efficiency. This makes them especially suitable when moving water and unstable ground are a concern.

  1. Economical

Gabion walls are more economical in terms of both labor and material than other alternatives, especially when the filler material is available on-site.

  1. Strength

Gabion walls are very strong and stable. This makes them especially suitable for resisting torrential force, flood forces, earth and ice pressure.

  1. Eco-friendly

Recycled materials can be used as a filler and placed in the gabion cage. The soil in the gaps between filling materials allows vegetation to grow over time. Also, the materials used in gabion construction are not affected by the elements and, therefore, do not affect the environment.

Gabion Maintenance

Gabion structures consist of steel wire mesh treated with an anti-corrosion agent, filled with a granular material to form a gravity structure. The weight of the structure enables it to resist the pressure exerted on it from behind. Although gabion walls are very durable, they are still susceptible to mechanical damage due to impact and deformation.

Gabion maintenance involves visual inspection, usually done annually. Any damage spotted during the inspection should be dealt with according to the purpose of the gabion. Gabion walls that serve essential purposes like damming should be repaired immediately to stop further damage and minimize the risk they pose in that damaged state.

Abnormalities spotted during the visual inspection of gabion walls may include: broken components, localized bulging of the face, vegetation at the face, damage by vandalism or impact, or excessive water through the face.

What should you look out for when inspecting a Gabion?

  1. Local Minor Impact Damage

Individual broken, split or damaged cage components don't affect the gabion's structural integrity and can be repaired on the spot if need be. However, if several gabion components are broken in the same area, this may affect other areas' integrity on the gabion wall. Professionals should repair the damage.

  1. Major Collision Damage

This might pose a massive risk to the gabion wall's structural integrity and should, therefore, be repaired by professionals since they may require rebuilding with localized support for the landfill or water body behind the gabion wall.

  1. Excavations near the Wall

The presence of an excavation near the gabion wall may affect the structure's integrity. However, the extent to which the excavation poses a risk depends on its depth and proximity to the gabion wall. Any excavation deeper than 0.5 meters near the wall may affect the foundation's stability and lead to the gabion wall's collapse.

  1. Vegetation

Gabion cages are filled with inert crushed stones, so they are not susceptible to vegetation growth from within the wall. Vegetation growing on top of the wall does not affect the structure in any way. However, any vegetation growing from within the gabion should be removed immediately.

Shitai Product Page

Geotextiles

Geotextiles are semipermeable textile materials used to improve soil characteristics. They can filter, separate, reinforce, protect, and drain when used together with the soil. Geotextiles are ideal for a wide variety of infrastructure works such as roads, landfills, harbors, and other civil engineering projects.

Types of Geotextile

Geotextiles are made from polymers like polyester and propylene. They are classified into three categories based on how they are made. They include:

  1. Woven fabric geotextiles
  2. Knitted geotextiles
  3. Non-woven geotextiles
  1. Woven Fabric Geotextiles

These are some of the most commonly used geotextiles. They are manufactured using the same techniques used to manufacture typical clothing textiles. The weaving process involves slit film yarns, multifilament or monofilament yarns being woven in the machine and cross machine direction. The thread running along the length is called the warp, and the one running perpendicular is called the weft. Woven fabrics can be constructed with polyester or polypropylene or a combination of the two.

  1. Knitted Geotextiles

Knitted geotextiles are made by interlocking a series of loops of yarn together. They are manufactured using the knitting technique in conjunction with other geosynthetic manufacturing methods, such as weaving and are generally made with polyester.

  1. Non-woven Geotextile

Non-woven geotextiles are constructed from a short staple fiber or a continuous filament polyester or polypropylene fiber. The fiber bonding is done through mechanical or chemical techniques or a combination of both including needle punch construction.

Those manufactured through mechanical interlocking or thermal bonding have a thickness of 0.5 to 1mm, while chemically bonded geotextiles have a thickness of up to 3mm.

Functions of Geotextiles

  1. Separation.

During the manufacture of roads, geotextiles are used to prevent the intermixing of two adjacent soils. A similar approach is used in gabion wall and other retaining wall applications by separating soil from the gabion fill or the drainage stone from the soil fill material. An excellent example of this application in roads is when there is subgrade soil bordering an aggregate coarse soil. In this case, a geotextile is used to preserve the aggregate soil's strength characteristics and drainage.

  1. Filtration

Geotextiles aid soil conservation by allowing water to drain freely through the soil with limited soil loss. The geotextile’s porosity and permeability aid this action.

  1. Reinforcement

The introduction of geotextiles in the soil enhances the soil's structural integrity, much like what steel does to concrete.

  1. Sealing

During road construction and repair, a layer of non-woven geotextile is placed between existing and new asphalt layers. It then absorbs the asphalt, thus acting as a waterproof membrane layer that minimizes the flow of water into the pavement.

Gabion walls have been in use for more than 7000 years now. Although they were initially used as a means of soil conservation, their applications have increased tremendously in military and civil engineering projects. Gabion walls are relatively simple structures, but it is essential to consult a civil engineer whenever you want to use them for large and sensitive projects. Doing so will ensure that the structure not only lasts longer but also provides the desired outcome.

Gabion Walls - Complete Guide to Building with ...

Gabion walls are retaining walls built by stacking stone in a gabion cage or gabion basket that can serve many purposes but are most often used to create tiered or leveled ground in gardens. 

They are rectangular baskets of metallic lattice filled with stones and their origin dates back to war times when they were erected to protect against artillery fire. Since then, they have been employed to contain soil when leveling a building site, or as erosion control along waterfronts, and often as an acoustic screen for sound reduction along highways; not as attractive as a coniferous barrier but certainly faster. 

While it’s hard to predict the future, modern architect-designed homes and zero carbon homes often introduce industrial looks to the interior and exterior aesthetics of homes and commercial buildings, and many are already using gabion walls for structures and even aesthetic accents now. So this may increasingly become a popular building trend as it's certainly easier than trying to build a dry stone wall for most people.

They are also more frequently being seen installed in urban areas and parks as partition walls or even as outdoor furniture. They can also be covered with dirt and used to introduce plants. Of course, over time, nature will supply many varieties to fill the structure if you don’t get in first.

Gabion retaining walls in modern architecture

Gabion walls in modern architect-designed homes

Gabion walls are an integral part of the design of the ZEB Pilot House

The ZEB Pilot house in Norway is a good example incorporating gabion stone cages in home design where they are used to build both interior and exterior walls. This single-family, demonstration house is the result of a collaboration between the architectural and design firm Snohetta and Scandinavia's largest research institute SINTEF, in partnership with Brødrene Dahl et Optimera.

This house was designed and built with reduced carbon concrete and minimal plastic, and it achieves a neutral carbon footprint while offering an extraordinary visual. However, we're not 100% sure how air infiltration is controlled through the gabion cage walls, so we will run with the assumption that the architects have included an air barrier component to the wall system.  

Gabion walls used for structure and aesthetics in the ZEB Pilot House 

More about gabion walls:

  • Gabion walls are suitable for all types of terrain; 
  • They do not require any special maintenance; 
  • Offer good acoustic performance (for use as a soundproofing wall, it is best to use porous stones);
  • Built walls are flexible (they can shift without breaking or cracking; excellent for earthquake areas); 
  • Quick to install;
  • Do not require masonry; 
  • The cavities will have voids of 25 to 35% that can be filled with soil to encourage plant growth and act as a berm for flood protection; 
  • Their appearance can vary depending on the color and consistency of the stones chosen.

How much do gabion walls cost?

The nice surprise for gabion walls is how affordable they can be. While a dry stacked stone wall aesthetic adds to the cost of putting up a gabion wall rather than randomly pouring stone in with a mini excavator, it's still considerably more affordable than concrete or rammed earth walls.

 GABION WALL (LOOSE)

 COST($)

 DRY STONE WALL

 COST($)

 CONCRETE WALL

 COST($)

H = 3 Ft 100 H = 3 Ft 140 H = 3 Ft 1 150 H = 10 Ft 725 H = 10 Ft 1 315 H = 10 Ft 3 250 H = 16 Ft 1 900 H = 16 Ft 3 530 H = 16 Ft 4 560

Cost comparison of Gabion Walls to Concrete in USD

Carbon footprint of gabion walls

Gabion walls really do have a significantly lower carbon footprint than a concrete wall. Taking into account the embodied energy for the carbon footprint of a 10 foot high wall through all stages of it's life (manufacturing, transport, construction and maintenance)  - here are the comparative figures between 3 wall types:

WALL TYPES UBP MJeq Kg of CO2 emission Gabion 727 545 4 703 243 Dry Stone Wall 623 568 4 090 210 Concrete 1 777 335 9 491 757

Gabion walls have been shown to have about a third of the carbon footprint of a concrete wall. Although, once they achieve a height of about 16 feet, they begin to lose their advantage because of measures that would need to be taken to ensure stability, which makes it a more complicated construction process. For a free tool to calculate the carbon footprint in building materials see here.

How to build a gabion wall

The principle is quite simple: stones are dropped into welded mesh cages supported by galvanized aluminum alloy or steel metal rods) that are embedded in the ground. Done!   

Gabion walls are steel cages filled with stones or other materials

The filling can be of all shapes and colors of granite or other stones. An important point to make when building a gabion wall in a cold climate – be sure to use non-porous stones that don’t absorb water and then freeze and crack in the winter.

The size of the stones can vary quite a bit from small to large, but the typical diameter you can expect to see is between 4 and 8 inches. From a design point of view, it is worth noting that gabions are not limited to stone. Some are made with other materials such as oyster shells, wood, bark or recycled glass. 

Gabion wall filled with oyster shells

As for the steel used in the baskets, it must be galvanized or stainless steel to ensure a long life, especially if the wall will be subject to salt spray such as those built close to the ocean or on the sides of roads in cold areas where roads are salted in winter. We would also recommend raw metal rather than the ones covered with PVC, as there is already more than enough vinyl building products in the world.

Measure thoroughly before erecting your retaining wall, because you will need to take into account various parameters such as the characteristics of the filling materials, the density and percentage of the voids of the materials, plus the resistance of the mesh, shape and varying size. The soil type and embankment of the location are also important considerations, as the weight of the gabion must overcome the push of the ground behind, as well as any foundations (depth and type).

A high water table might limit your options for a gabion wall too - unless outside and the water streaks and stains add to the aesthetic you're going for. 

Gabion cages can be used to build exterior garden furniture

Gabion vs. concrete: carbon emissions 

The gabion wall has many advantages both economically and ecologically. From an environmental aspect in terms of reducing the impact of the built environment on climate change, avoiding concrete is always a good thing. Unless you choose a carbon storage concrete option with a lowered carbon footprint as seen here. 

In its report ‘Retaining Walls – an Environmental and Financial Comparison of Different Technologies’, a team specializing in civil engineering and environment based in Lyon, France, has produced a comparison between dry-stone gabion and concrete. 

The conclusion was that the gabion wall wins hands down in a comparative match when considering both the climate impact of carbon emissions as well as the financial cost of construction. 

Downsides of gabion walls:

Quite frankly, there aren’t a lot of disadvantages to gabion walls compared to concrete. The main one would be the height, in that they cannot be built as high as concrete. The second would really be aesthetics, and whether or not you like the appearance. The third thing, that we're going to continue to investigate for when using gabion cage walls for home building, is how to prevent air infiltration into and out of homes with gabion walls. But that really is about it. If there are more downsides to gabion walls that you have experienced, please let us know in the comments section below - as well as any other advantages, materials or uses you may have tried successfully. We've even found gabion cages or baskets online at reasonable cost here - add some locally sourced loose stone and gabion walls look like an interesting and alternative option to concrete for building walls, as well as their traditional gardening planter use.

If you want to learn more, please visit our website Custom Gabion.